Best Places to Shop in and Around Lake Tippecanoe

Lake Tippecanoe is more than Indiana’s deepest natural lake—it’s a lifestyle. Surrounded by serene waters, rolling woodlands, and small-town charm, the area offers visitors and residents an escape from the everyday. While known for boating and recreation, Lake Tippecanoe is also near an impressive selection of boutique shopping destinations. From water sports gear and home furnishings to handcrafted gifts and local delicacies, shoppers will find a diverse and delightful mix of retail options in the nearby towns of Winona Lake and Warsaw. Here's a comprehensive look at the best places to shop in and around Lake Tippecanoe.

Located right on the shores of Lake Tippecanoe in Leesburg, Tippecanoe Boat Company is the go-to destination for boating enthusiasts. This full-service marina and boat dealership offers a premium selection of new and pre-owned watercraft, including Godfrey Pontoons, Lund Boats, Sanpan, Aqua Patio, and Monaco Sweetwater. Whether you're investing in your first boat or upgrading your current setup, the knowledgeable team at Tippecanoe Boat Company provides expert guidance, maintenance services by factory-trained technicians, and top-tier customer care. They also offer seasonal boat storage and rentals, making this an essential stop for lake lovers year-round.

Just a short drive from Lake Tippecanoe, The Village at Winona in Winona Lake is a unique, walkable retail district set against a charming canal. Here, you’ll find an eclectic collection of specialty shops, each offering something distinct and thoughtfully curated. From artisan goods to outdoor gear, it’s a haven for shoppers looking for one-of-a-kind finds in a beautiful lakeside setting.

For jewelry lovers and creative spirits, The Beaded Peacock is a standout destination. This charming boutique specializes in beads, findings, and handmade jewelry created by Indiana artists. Shoppers can participate in daily Make & Take projects, jewelry-making classes, or even host private events such as birthday parties and girls’ nights. The Beaded Peacock brings a personal and hands-on approach to crafting wearable art.

BELOVE blends curated gifting with conscious consumerism. This boutique features handcrafted jewelry, vintage goods, pottery, plants, and other delightful items that are often locally made or benefit charitable causes. The jewelry bar allows visitors to create customized keepsakes, and 5% of every purchase supports local mission-minded organizations. It’s a shop that lets customers give back while treating themselves or a loved one.

Gourmet enthusiasts will love Canal Street Market, a specialty food shop dedicated to unique culinary items. With a well-stocked inventory of gourmet teas, spices, and hard-to-find ingredients, it’s the perfect stop for home chefs or gift givers. The market elevates everyday cooking with thoughtful products that inspire creativity in the kitchen.

Part surf shop, part water sports outfitter, The Lakehouse is Winona Lake’s go-to destination for those who live for sun and surf. Featuring trendy apparel from O’Neill, Ripcurl, Tommy Bahama, and more, it caters to the fashion-forward lake lifestyle. Boating accessories and wake products are also available, along with rentals for pontoons, paddleboards, and kayaks. It’s a must-visit for those looking to hit the water in style.

LetterWood Paper Co. is a charming studio dedicated to fine, hand-painted paper goods. With greeting cards, calendars, and custom invitations crafted with artistic flair, this shop celebrates the beauty of handwritten notes and paper artistry. Every product is made in-house or locally sourced, making it a great place for meaningful, personalized gifts.

For fashion and beauty enthusiasts, Luxe Studio & Boutique combines salon-quality hair care services with a boutique offering high-end women’s apparel and accessories. With a commitment to keeping styles fresh and unique—never reordering the same item twice—Luxe caters to those who want to stand out and feel their best.

The Mucky Duck specializes in elegant home décor, unique gifts, and original artwork. From whimsical accents to sophisticated pieces, the shop’s curated collection helps shoppers find meaningful additions for their homes or memorable gifts for others. It’s a delightful browsing experience filled with color, creativity, and charm.

This wellness-focused shop offers natural soaps and skincare products handcrafted with the highest quality ingredients. Nine Pines Apothecary also features a variety of distinctive gift items, emphasizing sustainability, self-care, and holistic living. It's a cozy and calming stop for health-conscious shoppers.

Foodies will appreciate The Olive Branch, which offers a tasting experience of world-class olive oils and aged balsamic vinegars. Imported from both hemispheres for peak freshness, their EVOOs and balsamics are a staple for gourmet kitchens. Shoppers can sample everything before buying and explore additional products like pasta mixes, spouts, and specialty foods.

Wine lovers should not miss Port Winona, a curated wine and gourmet shop offering meats, cheeses, and an impressive selection of wine and beer. With classes and tastings available, it’s also a social hub for enthusiasts wanting to expand their palate in a relaxed, friendly environment.

At Pottery Bayou, shoppers are the artists. This paint-your-own pottery studio encourages creativity in a casual, welcoming environment. With options for walk-ins, group events, and workshops, it’s perfect for crafting memorable gifts or keepsakes.

Step into Rocket Fizz and be transported back in time. This nostalgic candy and soda shop offers thousands of retro and novelty treats alongside quirky gag gifts and collectibles. It’s a joyful experience for all ages, whether you’re revisiting childhood favorites or discovering new ones.

Trailhouse Village Bicycles supports outdoor living with a wide range of bicycles, gear, and apparel. With professional repair services and a bike fitting studio, this shop meets the needs of casual riders and serious cyclists alike. It’s also a hub for local cycling enthusiasts looking to connect.

This beloved general store is brimming with character. Winona Mercantile offers nostalgic gifts, home goods, apparel, specialty foods, and unique finds like WoodWick candles and Lakegirl apparel. It's a charming reminder of traditional retail values with modern sensibilities.

Downtown Warsaw, just west of Lake Tippecanoe, adds even more shopping options in a lively, historic setting. With its picturesque streets and welcoming storefronts, Warsaw blends small-town warmth with contemporary shopping.

Serving northern Indiana for over 40 years, Male Fashions is a trusted source for men’s casual and formalwear. From custom orders to tux rentals, the store is known for its personalized service and extensive selection. It’s the go-to shop for style-conscious men preparing for everyday wear or special events.

Glam Boutique is a fashion-forward destination catering to the modern woman. Focused on empowering customers through personal style, Glam offers clothing, accessories, and an elevated shopping experience. It's more than a store—it’s a community for women to explore and express themselves.

With nearly nine decades of service, Reinholt’s Town Square Furniture is a cornerstone of home furnishing in Warsaw. Their customer-first approach and wide inventory make furniture shopping simple and enjoyable. Offering delivery and setup, they make it easy to turn a house into a home.

While Lake Tippecanoe is celebrated for its natural beauty and recreation, the surrounding areas offer an equally rich shopping experience. From boating gear and outdoor lifestyle essentials to boutique fashion and locally made treasures, the region blends lakeside leisure with retail variety. Whether browsing quaint shops in Winona Lake or enjoying the vibrant culture of downtown Warsaw, visitors and locals alike will find no shortage of ways to shop local and support the communities around Lake Tippecanoe.

The Deb Paton Showley Group can help you find your perfect home near the best shopping destinations in northern Indiana. Their team of real estate professionals offers unmatched knowledge of the area, personalized service, and a passion for connecting clients with the lifestyle they deserve. Discover the difference with a team that understands what makes this region special.